Pittsburgh Penguins vs Columbus Blue Jackets

League: NHL | Date: 2026-01-17 07:00 PM EST | Last Updated: 2026-01-17 08:00 AM EST

💰 Best Bet #1 Penguins / Spread / -1.5 at +120 / 55% / Penguins show strong home form with superior xGF metrics in recent games, covering the puck line against weaker defenses like Columbus, supported by line movement favoring the favorite despite public lean.

💰 Best Bet #2 Under / Total / 5.5 at -110 / 60% / Both teams exhibit low-scoring trends in divisional matchups, with Penguins’ defense allowing under 2.8 goals per game and Blue Jackets struggling offensively post-injuries; flipped from model over projection based on historical NHL accuracy.

💰 Best Bet #3 Penguins / Moneyline / -150 / 65% / Pittsburgh’s home-ice advantage and better overall roster depth give them a clear edge over a rebuilding Columbus squad, with positive EV from sharp money alignment.

Pittsburgh Penguins vs Columbus Blue Jackets on 2026-01-17

Game Times
ET: 07:00 PM
CT: 06:00 PM
MT: 05:00 PM
PT: 04:00 PM
AKT: 03:00 PM
HST: 01:00 PM

💸 Public Bets
Penguins 65% / Blue Jackets 35%

💰 Money Distribution
Penguins 55% / Blue Jackets 45%

💹 Market Alignment
Divergent

📉 Line Movement
Stable at Penguins -1.5; opened -1.5 and held firm despite 65% public on Pittsburgh, indicating sharp balance on underdog side.

💡 Mathematical Edge (EV)
+3% on Penguins spread; reverse line movement against public percentage suggests professional action on home team, confirmed by Penguins’ superior Corsi% (52.3%) vs. Columbus’ 47.1% in current season matchups.

Simulation Results
| Metric | Value |
|——–|——-|
| Win % for Pittsburgh Penguins | 60% |
| Win % for Columbus Blue Jackets | 30% |
| Tie % | 10% |
| Spread Cover % for Pittsburgh Penguins -1.5 | 45% |
| Over/Under Probability | Over: 55% / Under: 45% |
| Average Total Goals | 5.7 |
| 95% Confidence Interval for Margin | [-2.0, 4.0] |

Top 3 Player Props
Player Prop #1: Sidney Crosby / Over Points / 0.5 at -130 / 70% / Crosby averages 1.1 points per game at home this season with high usage against Columbus’ weak PK (78.2%), facing a depleted Blue Jackets defense.

Player Prop #2: Zach Werenski / Under Shots on Goal / 3.5 at -110 / 65% / Werenski’s shot volume drops to 2.8 per game vs. Penguins’ stout forecheck, with recent form showing under in 4 of last 5, supported by Pittsburgh’s low shots allowed (28.4).

Player Prop #3: Tristan Jarry / Under Goals Allowed / 2.5 at -120 / 68% / Jarry posts a .915 SV% at home, and Columbus averages just 2.2 goals on the road against top-10 goalies, with injuries limiting their top-line production.

⚖️ Analysis Summary
Public sentiment heavily favors the Penguins, but divergent money distribution hints at sharp interest in Columbus covering, though metrics like Penguins’ edge in high-danger chances (11.2 per game) support following the favorite. The game outlook leans toward a moderate-scoring affair, with both teams’ defensive efficiencies (Penguins 2.71 GA/G, Blue Jackets 3.12) pointing to under the total despite pace factors. Overall, contrarian logic applies selectively here, as EV favors the home spread without full public fade.

🔮 Recommended Play
Follow the public with Penguins — superior form, home advantage, and simulation win probability align for the moneyline and spread edges.

Highlights unavailable.